I was so happy to see this app appear in the app store, but I was so disappointed in this initial version. The good news is that the video playback seems to be at least as good as on the iPad app. Now the bad news; there are three major problems:
1. Discovery – To connect to your DiskStation, you need to enter its IP address. On the Apple TV remote. The hostname doesn’t work; it needs to be the full IP address. Maybe this is OK on the Roku, but I doubt most Apple TV users even know what an IP address is. This needs to change to automatic discovery.
2. Authentication – To authenticate, you need to enter your DiskStation user name and password. Again, this is only the Apple TV remote. You need to type your precious password in slowly character by character on a big screen. Granted, a lot of Apple TV apps have this problem, but there needs to be a way to do this off screen. Maybe tie it into the phone app to authenticate. And in case anyone missed your password on the big screen, it looks like it sends your credentials unencrypted over the LAN.
3. Navigation – This is actually the biggest problem, and the reason I can’t use the current version of this app. The navigation basically relies solely on the artwork. If you don’t have artwork, there aren’t enough characters of the filename shown below to uniquely identify the file. Arrange the titles vertically, so we don’t cram in all these titles side-by-side horizontally.